Showing posts with label Job. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Job. Show all posts

Tuesday, February 12, 2013

Wrestling With the Final Chapters of Job and Reflecting on the Depressed Person

The final chapters of the book of Job are some of the most scary and comforting verses in all the Bible. Hard to handle for sure. Carl Trueman comments:
Preaching through Job recently, I was very struck by the Lord's final intervention. Job has suffered incredibly throughout the book; and we, the readers, know that none of this is his fault. It is the result of the battle between God and the Accuser and, if anything, Job's suffering is thus the result of his devotion to the Lord, which Satan wishes to test. And by the end of Job's last big speech (Job 31) he is depressed, and with good reason. The man has lost everything.

When God finally comes to Job, to this man who has suffered so much devastation, it is stunning that he comes in the whirlwind. No still small voice here: he comes in the whirlwind (and a brief search of 'whirlwind' passages in the Old Testament indicates that is not indicative of what we might call good bedside manner). Further, the Lord tells Job to arm himself as a man ('man up', I guess, would be the modern cliché) and then, rather than telling Job to deal with his own sin or even expressing the tiniest fragment of sympathy for him in his suffering, he subjects Job to a blistering lecture about divine greatness and sovereignty. Then, when Job has been crushed into silence, the Lord pushes on relentlessly, describing two terrifying beasts, Behemoth and Leviathan. If Robert Fyall's exegesis is correct (and I believe it is) then Leviathan is Satan; thus, only at this point does God offer any real help (as we might understand it) to Job, as he lifts the curtain just a little and allows Job to grasp that his suffering is a function of a greater and more complicated universe than he can possibly imagine, and that, whatever the empirical facts, the Lord has ultimate and overall control.

As I preached on this passage, I highlighted the fact that, by the criteria of today's world, even by the criteria of modern pastoral theology, the Lord is a total failure. Far too abrupt, harsh and unsympathetic. This is even more striking, given that the Lord knows that Job's suffering is nothing to do with any specific sin Job has committed or harbours in his heart. Job is not responsible for his own suffering: that is, after all, the basic premise of the book.Yet the Lord comes in the whirlwind. Not exactly touchy-feely pastoral, is it?

The Lord knows Job's suffering is not Job's fault. Thus, he does not tell Job to examine himself to root out his sin. Further, he seems to show no sympathy for Job; he berates him from the whirlwind; he offers no kind words of encouragement; and he does not even restore Job until after the sacrifice and intercession of the last chapter. We should also ask: how complete was Job's restoration? This man had lost ten children. Yes, he receives ten more. But children are not like iPods: they have individual identities, faces, histories, personalities. The loving father knows that each and every one of his children is, quite literally, irreplaceable. How many nights in later life would Job have lain awake, remembering with a broken heart the names and faces and the stories and the good times of his first children? And none of this was anything to do with Job's own sins or faults.

The lessons of Job are manifold but it seems that a few rather stand out: this is acomplicated, fallen, evil world; Christians can expect to suffer - hey, we all die in the end, no matter how jolly we might feel at points in the interim, so we had better get used to the idea; Christians are no more exempt from depression than they are from cancer or strokes; and the idea that these things are necessarily linked to our lack of faith, to our personal sin, to our outlook on life, or, indeed, to anything intrinsic to us, is nonsense and unbiblical. A pastoral theology which has not grappled with the whirlwind and the speeches of the last part of Job is sub-biblical; and preaching which does not take these things into account is not biblical preaching. One might add that perhaps one of the key lessons of Job (and the Psalms, for that matter) is: it is OK to be depressed. It is horrible and grim and dark. But it may not be your fault, any more than cancer or a stroke are your fault. Above all, it does not mean that you are forgotten by God, even if God only ever seems to come to you in the whirlwind; and, finally, it does not mean that you will not participate in the glorious resurrection when all the travails of this world will be definitively left behind.

Wednesday, September 12, 2012

The "Why" in our Suffering is a Prison

Tullian:

There’s no doubt, the Why questions of suffering are utterly perplexing. And as we search the Scriptures and consider stories such as Job’s, we are tempted to see those as worst-case scenarios designed to help us get our heads straight in relation to our comparatively small “first world” problems. We look for ways to manage pain. We medicate; we minimize; we moralize. We rage, and we run. We develop theories to explain what is happening to us. While they may temporarily help us categorize and compartmentalize our thoughts and feelings, when true suffering comes, all our speculations fall flat. The Why’s of suffering keep us shrouded in a seemingly bottomless void of abstraction where God is reduced to a finite ethical agent, a limited psychological personality, whose purposes measure on the same scale as ours.
Read the rest.



Books by Tullian:

Friday, February 05, 2010

The Providence of God

The Providence of God (Contours of Christian Theology)What is impossible for us to do is to provide an intellectually satisfying answer to the “why” question. For asking such a question can only call for the answer, “Because God willed it to be so.”  To the subsequent question, “Why did God will it to be so?” there is no further, illuminating answer.  This is one reason that the pattern of divine providence will, in this life at least, always be a mystery.
In dealing with the providence of God, therefore, we are dealing with matters of ultimate significance for which there is no further explanation.  This does not mean that God is arbitrary or capricious in his dealings with the created universe. What it does mean is that the will of God, and the holy and wise reasons that he has for the exercise of that will, are the highest court of appeal (highest in the logical sense). There cannot be a higher court, and so, unsatisfactory though it may be, we must rest content with the ultimate reference to the will of God.
- Paul Helm, The Providence of God (Contours of Christian Theology)


(HT:  John Starke)

Wednesday, May 27, 2009

Job 38-41 As Prescription For Just About Anything

In his book, When People Are Big And God Is Small, Ed Welch says that spending some time reading God's response to Job's questions about his suffering in Job 38-41 is a great treatment for just about any problem. Why is this? Because catching a vision for God's sovereignty, grandeur, power, and control leaves us feeling very small. When we are small, and God is really really big, our problems tend to follow and be small as well. In fact, this was Job's experience and he testifies to it when he says in Job 40:4:
"Behold, I am of small account; what shall I answer you?"
A couple weeks ago in our home group we simple took 15 minutes and read aloud Job 38-41. I think this is a great discipline for us to make a habit of. It's a great way of actualizing the desire of John the Baptist in reference to Jesus in John 3:30:
"He must increase, but I must decrease.”

Wednesday, January 21, 2009

Some Insights From The Book Of Job From Dr. Greg Perry

I found these quotes from Dr. Perry's lecture this morning on Job to be insightful, especially as it applies to learning to have wisdom in dealing with those who are suffering. We would be wise to take heed!
What we all need is someone who will be an advocate for us; to be a mediator for us. They (Job's friends) do not offer to do that. For all the talking, there is lots of it, on and on and on, that is part of the point, it just goes on and on, is there no end to this? For all the words of his well meaning friends, never once, not one word is spoken directly to God on Job’s behalf. Never once do they pray for him. They are only talking to Job and trying to explain his situation. They never advocate for Job.

One great lesson here is that we need take away is that part of the reason they are seen as miserable comforters is that they never interceded for Job. They are with Job, so give them credit for that. They didn’t ignore him, but they needed to go to God with Job and that they never do.

And then a little later in the lecture:
Beware of theological machines. Eliphaz (the first friend to speak to Job, he thinks Job is suffering due to his personal wrongdoing) is naive in his orthodoxy. It’s not that he doesn’t understand something about God in that he rewards obedience but he assumes too much knowledge about why it’s happening. We (the readers) have seen behind the curtain and we know that Job's suffering is happening EXACTLY because he is blameless. This is the irony. Eliphaz has over-reached in his explanation of what is happening in Job’s life.

Monday, January 19, 2009

Job and Justice

As I leave today for a class on the book of Job, I found this post to be a helpful reminder from Michael Kelley:

“Justice” is a red hot term right now, and like all red hot terms, different people mean different things when they say it. But as I was reading in DA Carson’s How Long O Lord? this week, he used the term in a more classical way. He used it in the context of Job.

If you remember, the whole story of Job is pretty tragic and even more mysterious. Job, though a righteous man, lost everything he had, and when he was left with nothing, came before God seeking justice. Job’s claim was that what had happened to him was unjust, and he wanted an explanation. He wanted justice.

I think we do that sometimes. We lose a job, someone gets sick, The Office is a rerun – whatever. We complain, and we want justice. But there’s a fallacy in our desire. When we cry out for justice, we assume that justice will work out in our favor. But it won’t. Not really.

Carson has a helpful, if difficult, reminder – that the only place in the universe where justice is immediately and proportionally dispensed is hell. And if God were to start doing that on earth, then earth would very quickly become hell.

God is just, and we should love and want to see His justice. But we also ought to be careful what we wish for, so that we don’t ask Him for justice when what we really want is convenience and comfort.

Tuesday, December 23, 2008

Will There Also Be Faith?

"This is, at the end of the day, the ultimate test of our knowledge of God. Is it robust enough that, when faced with excruciating adversity, it may prompt us to lash out with hard questions, but will never permit us to turn away form God?

But perhaps it is better to put the matter the other way round: the God who put Job through this wringer is also the God of whom it is said that, with respect to his own people, "he will not let (them) be tempted beyond what (they) can bear. But when (they) are tempted, he will also provide a way out so that (they) can endure it" (1 Cor. 10:13). God could not trust me with as much suffering as Job endured; I could not take it. But we must not think that there was any doubt in God's mind as to whether he would win his wager with Satan over Job!

When we suffer, there will sometimes be mystery. Will there also be faith?"

- D.A. Carson, How Long O Lord?, p. 156

Saturday, October 18, 2008

Q and A on The Book of Job


I think John Piper is often at his best in Q and A sessions. You can click here to listen to the audio of Dr. Piper answering questions on the book of Job during a conference they recently held dealing with Job as the subject matter.

Here are the questions he deals with:
  • What language should we use to talk about God's sovereignty over sin?
  • How much did the Holy Spirit have to do with Job's ability to suffer well?
  • As an ancient believer, how was Job's faith different than ours?
  • How could Satan come into God's presence? Does he still?
  • Did God initiate the meeting with Satan?
  • How should we view Satan's involvement in our lives?
  • What is involved in the worship that comes in the moments of deepest suffering?
  • Would it be wrong to express anger and frustration in these moments?
  • How do you lovingly speak the truth of God's sovereignty to sufferers?
  • What does it mean to be righteous?
  • What does it mean for the righteous to suffer when there is none righteous before God?
  • How do we make sure our kids are prepared for suffering when our family has undergone so little?
  • What do you say to a couple who lost their infant and now God seems so far away?
  • How do I help my disabled child understand God's sovereignty when she faces not just physical suffering, but emotional suffering because of continual ridicule?
  • What do you do for an unbelieving friend whose suffering is pushing her away from God?
  • What do you do when you can't see God's good purposes in suffering?
You can find the other messages from the conference here.