Very interesting piece of writing here from Jonathan Leeman.
Does Christianity have anything to offer in the public square?
Showing posts with label Cultural Engagement. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Cultural Engagement. Show all posts
Wednesday, April 16, 2014
Wednesday, April 09, 2014
Astute Cultural Analysis Here
Zachary Fine:
Those of us born after the mid-1980s whose upbringing included a liberal arts education and the fruits of a fledgling World Wide Web have grown up (and are still growing up) with an endlessly accessible stream of texts, images and sounds from far-reaching times and places, much of which were unavailable to humans for all of history. Our most formative years include not just the birth of the Internet and the ensuing accelerated global exchange of information, but a new orthodoxy of multiculturalist ethics and “political correctness.”Read the rest.
These ideas were reinforced in many humanities departments in Western universities during the 1980s, where facts and claims to objectivity were eagerly jettisoned. Even “the canon” was dislodged from its historically privileged perch, and since then, many liberal-minded professors have avoided opining about “good” literature or “high art” to avoid reinstating an old hegemony. In college today, we continue to learn about the byproducts of absolute truths and intractable forms of ideology, which historically seem inextricably linked to bigotry and prejudice.
For instance, a student in one of my English classes was chastened for his preference for Shakespeare over that of the Haitian-American writer Edwidge Danticat. The professor challenged the student to apply a more “disinterested” analysis to his reading so as to avoid entangling himself in a misinformed gesture of “postcolonial oppression.” That student stopped raising his hand in class.
I am not trying to tackle the challenge as a whole or indict contemporary pedagogies, but I have to ask: How does the ethos of pluralism inside universities impinge on each student’s ability to make qualitative judgments outside of the classroom, in spaces of work, play, politics or even love?
Friday, April 04, 2014
Monday, March 10, 2014
The Gospel of the Cross and the Grace to Disagree
Very interesting insights here.
Derek Rishmawy:
Derek Rishmawy:
Pick a hot subject (gay marriage, the environment, healthcare, and so on) and scroll through your Facebook feed to find someone updating vociferously on the subject, trumpeting his position and damning the opposition in bold, apocalyptic terms. It's not just that people are wrong, confused, and perhaps in need of correction; no, they're downright wicked. As younger generations increasingly identify as "nones" (no religious affiliation), it's not that they have no moral or spiritual bearings, just that they find them elsewhere.
It's increasingly popular to eschew any explicit religious system and take that bearing from the reigning "Causes" linked to the benevolence demands of the day ("love," "justice," "equality"). This is why our political skirmishes aren't just about the issues. They're about a much-deeper justification of the Self. If I'm defined, say, by my healthcare position and corresponding self-image as a moral, caring (or pragmatic and free) person, then when I argue with you, I'm defending my raison-d'etre. You don't simply have a different opinion on a subject; you threaten my very being.
What's more, if supporting this Cause is what makes me righteous and pure, your opposition demonstrates your impurity and wickedness, possibly even your inhumanity. You must be opposed, hopefully only through argument. But if you persist in your perversity, other stronger means of enforcement may need to be employed. This is modern/postmodern ideological moralism.
None of this moralism is new, of course. Postmodern thinkers have been describing the way we construct such oppositional identities for years. What's interesting today, though, is how this sort of logic works out in the lives of my peers and contemporaries. Of course, posting aggressive memes on Facebook isn't exactly coercion or fanatic violence, but the language used and, at times, the political measures advocated by partisans verges on it. Ideological self-justification is alive and well.
The Gospel of the Cross and the Grace to Disagree
Christians reading this analysis might be tempted to take it as a simple condemnation of secularists, saying, "See, look what happens when you don't have God." Perhaps, but that problem doesn't let religious believers off the hook. As a friend of mine observed, this is simply the logic of Holy War, sublimated and secularized. Again, we see how the whole dichotomy of "religious" versus "secular" breaks down at the functional level. Get rid of God and something else fills the existential vacuum. At this point secularists are only doing what religious people, including "Christians," have done with their gods for years.
Actually, this observation should prompt Christians to examine where we're getting our sense of self, our purity, and our wholeness. Is it from the righteousness of our moral positions? Or from the righteousness we have in Christ by grace apart from our moral achievements? If the former, we're in the same boat as secularists. If the latter, we're positioned to disagree, even forcefully, without our entire sense of self feeling threatened. Even if others oppose us not only on moral issues but actually set themselves in vocal opposition to Christianity itself, how can we look on them as totally different from ourselves? For is this not precisely who we were apart from God's condescending grace—enemies of God in need of redemption (Rom. 5:6-11)? And are we not secure no matter what accusation or charge is brought against us (Rom. 8:30-39)?
In short, there's a visible, practical difference we observe in the lives of those who trust in the Christian gospel as opposed to those who merely subscribe to its morals. Indeed, unless you believe the former you won't be able to practice the core of the latter—the command to love our enemies the way Christ has loved us. Moralism—secular or "religious"—can only lead to demonizing the enemy. And only the gospel of grace can lead us to the true benevolence that moralism fumblingly strives toward.Read the rest.
Wednesday, February 12, 2014
The White Guy Who Doesn't Know How To Talk About Race
Barnabas Piper offers some honest reflections on being white and wanting to seek change in reference to racial issues but isn't sure where to start. Obviously he is writing in general terms as he speaks about "white people" but his contribution to the discussion is valuable and I'm sure many can relate.
Thursday, February 06, 2014
Lessons from the Ken Ham vs. Bill Nye Creation Debate
Helpful thoughts here from Rick Phillips. I found his third point to be quite instructive. There is certainly an impulse in me to not look like one of the "fringe weirdos". "Please accept me!" as a guiding emotional compass will eventually lead one down a path that leads to great despair.
There certainly is a place for a worthy critique of Ken Ham and his ministry, but at the end of the day whether you are a literal 6 day, 24 hour believer or not, all Christians are going to have to come to terms with the fact that many will write us off as wackos, unworthy of the simplest respect, unless we adhere to the reigning cultural narrative of blind, cold materialism. To the incoherence of this position may we never bend the knee. There are worse things than cultural ostracism.
There certainly is a place for a worthy critique of Ken Ham and his ministry, but at the end of the day whether you are a literal 6 day, 24 hour believer or not, all Christians are going to have to come to terms with the fact that many will write us off as wackos, unworthy of the simplest respect, unless we adhere to the reigning cultural narrative of blind, cold materialism. To the incoherence of this position may we never bend the knee. There are worse things than cultural ostracism.
How To Engage The Neighborhood
Great thoughts here from Jeff Cavanaugh.
He writes:
I would recommend this book as well.
He writes:
I serve my local church as deacon of community outreach, and our strategy for reaching the neighborhood around us is mainly one of long-term, patient faithfulness. Our goal is to build relationships with our neighbors that, over time, will make it easier for us to have spiritual conversations with them. These relationships also make our neighbors more willing to attend services and other events aimed specifically at engaging unbelievers with the gospel.Read the rest.
The basic principle behind this strategy is simple, and it's one any church can follow: engage your neighbors by taking an interest in what they care about. Building common ground is easy when you participate side-by-side in community organizations, service projects, family events, block parties, yard sales, and the like. Common interests are one of the most powerful tools for building friendships that can enable spiritual conversations to take place.
My church is located in a historic urban neighborhood that has a well-defined identity, and many of our neighbors have common interests. Neighborhood associations are popular and prominent in the life of the community, and events like street fairs, art shows, music festivals, park cleanups, and community yard sales are common. We engage our neighbors by having church members volunteer for these events, host booths, and attend neighborhood association meetings. We also invite the community to a couple of evangelistic events at Christmas: a service of lessons and carols with a brief evangelistic sermon, and a sing-along production of Handel's Messiah.
But even if your church doesn't have the advantages that my church's neighborhood affords, you can still engage your neighbors by showing you care about what's important to them. Just devote some time to thinking about what your neighbors value, what they spend their time and resources on, and ways you can build relationships with them through those things.
I would recommend this book as well.
Thursday, January 30, 2014
Cynicism Doesn’t Reach a Lost World
Good reflections here from Ed Stetzer:
Walt Disney World specializes in catching your attention—it's a paradise for people with ADD like me. There's something interesting everywhere you look. But the day I visited, there was one thing every person in the resort was certain to notice that wasn't part of the theme park.
I was in EPCOT at the time—trying to raise girls who know about a big world and about more than just princesses (or maybe just make them nerds like their dad)—when people around me started pointing to the sky. Being a dutiful sheep, I turned and looked as well.
What I saw were the letters "T-R-U-S." Like most anyone else would if they saw the smoke take shape, I assumed it would say to "trust" someone. Then a "J" was formed, and I joked out loud that it might say, "Trust Jess." But eventually, I figured out that it was "Trust Jesus"—I'm clever like that.
My reaction—and the reactions of others around me—seemed worthy of reflection.
First, my own instinct was to watch how others around me were responding. I have a high "hokey meter" and I wonder how people will respond to things that I perceive as hokey.
I tend to be skeptical of the effectiveness of barns painted with "For all that sinned and fall short of the glory of God," skywriters who write "Trust Jesus" in the sky, people who have T-shirts with catchy Christian phrases, and—as you may have noticed—church signs that I publish every week on the blog. So for me, both interest and some mild cynicism kicked in.
What I found most intriguing was the response of people who obviously were Christians. One couple nearby looked to one another and sort of rolled their eyes, then spoke aloud about how there are better ways to share the faith.
To some degree, I resonated with them. But since the skywriting went on for so long, I got to see the reaction of many people. In doing so, I was challenged-- and perhaps chastened.
Wednesday, January 29, 2014
Contextualized or Compromised?
Good reflections from Trevin Wax on movies and the intake of media in general.
Thursday, December 19, 2013
"You Offended Me!"
Jay Watts:
A young woman sat with her arms crossed and lips pursed while shooting me a look that must have been intended to vaporize me on the spot. I was talking to her and some of her fellow students about abortion and the pro-life position, and it clearly made her unhappy. She finally raised her hand and the whole room seemed to gird their loins for what was about to come. I asked her, “Did you have a question or comment?”She rather forcefully said, “I am offended that you would come here and say these things.”My response was as follows:Ok, let's talk about that for minute. I have presented an argument in support of the position that abortion is objectively wrong because it unjustly takes the life of an innocent human being. The lines of evidences that I appealed to were scientific (the identity of the unborn as a human life from fertilization) and philosophical (human beings have value by virtue of what they are not what they can do or how I feel about them).I also understand that hearing people argue for views you disagree with can be unpleasant. It bothers you to hear someone say you are wrong, just like it bothers anyone including me. I can get really irritated over people disagreeing with me about trivial things. It is natural to have emotional responses to discussions about all sorts of things, but especially about something as objectively important as abortion.Anytime someone disagrees with us and offers arguments for their position there are only a few options open to us in response. (1) We can quietly listen, consider their views, weigh the counter arguments, and decide they were wrong. (2) We can listen, consider, weigh, then decide we are wrong and adjust our beliefs appropriately. (3) We can listen, consider, weigh, and then decide that we simply lack sufficient information to come down on one side or the other. (4) We can offer counter arguments on the spot addressing the specific lines of evidence offered.All of those are perfectly appropriate. There are certainly counter arguments to everything that I have said today offered by genuinely brilliant people at an academic and sophisticated level. I've read them and learned from them, though I obviously found them less than persuasive in the end. I encourage you to find and read them and would be happy to point you in the right direction.But when you say that you are offended, all that you are doing is telling us how you are emotionally responding to what I am saying. I already conceded that we all struggle with our emotions in this kind of conversation, both in my original talk and just a moment ago, so you aren't adding anything to the discussion that addresses the substance of what was argued.Finally, and I'm not saying you are doing this, but when some people say they are offended what they are really saying is that I'm upsetting them so I ought to stop talking about abortion. I reject that all together. No one has a right not to be offended. Sometimes there are questions of such importance that we are compelled to engage in public discussion knowing that it will be upsetting to do so. Imagine how you would feel if someone suggested that you shouldn't be allowed to argue for positions with which they disagree simply because they are incapable of controlling their emotions.
What Russell Moore Says Here is Good For Everyone, Gay or Straight
He writes concerning the Duck Dynasty controversy:
The comments that seem most offensive to people are his moral assessments of sex outside of conjugal marriage, which were more or less just a recitation of the Apostle Paul’s words in 1 Corinthians 6. As Christians, we believe that Jesus is lord over sexuality, and he says that sexuality is expressed rightly only in the marriage of a man and a woman. That’s not new. We also think we’re all sinners, and that God calls us all to repentance. That’s not new either.Read the rest.
We’re a divided country on sexual issues. That’s why every news cycle brings more controversy. Why not engage one another, and have the debates in a civil fashion, without attempting to silence one another. I don’t agree with David Letterman’s views on divorce and cohabitation, but I don’t want him suspended for voicing them. I’ll bet I don’t agree with MTV’s Nev Schulman of the popular Catfish show on sexual ethics, but it wouldn’t put me in the fetal position under the table to hear him voice them.
Let’s have the sort of cultural conversation that allows us to seek to persuade each other, not to seek to silence one another with intimidation. That’s what real diversity is all about.
A few thoughts:
1. When a group of people feel have been persecuted in the past, I'm sure it's hard to have any desire to "have a conversation". I think this needs to be acknowledged by non-gay people. Compassion would be in order. Historically, many gay people have been treated very poorly by non-gay people in the majority culture. For gay people, if that music is always playing in the background, the desire to pull up a chair at the table of cultural conversation is greatly diminished.
2. When the assumption is that race issues and sexuality issues are exactly the same, it's a no-brainer that Phil gets fired. If Phil did an interview in GQ magazine and was spouting off about all the n*****s in the south, of course he should be fired from the show! Duh! So in this sense, when many in the gay community see race issues and sex issues as exactly the same, it's easy for them to take the moral high ground. This is not hard to figure out. If I believed that race and sexuality were the exact same thing I'd be first in line with them.
In light of this, I think we need to back the train up a bit and have a cultural conversation about race and sexuality. Are they exactly the same? What are the similarities? What are the differences? At this point though, that conversation doesn't feel safe to me. I fear that if I dared open my mouth and even hinted at the fact that race issues and sexuality issues are not completely parallel I'd be crucified in the public sphere.
3. Michael Kruger responded to the controversy in this blog post. Here is his proposed paragraph on what A&E and GLADD should have said in light of this controversy:
We here at GLAAD were disappointed to hear that Phil Robertson thinks homosexuality is a sin. We disagree. However, we acknowledge that he has the right to hold and proclaim these views, just as we have the right to hold and proclaim our views. If we want Americans to be more tolerant of homosexuality, we could hardly accomplish that goal by being intolerant of others who disagree with us. So, we want to say that we respect and tolerate Mr. Robertson’s views, even though we disagree with them. We hope this attitude of mutual respect can allow for more dialogue and conversation about these important issues.But again, if the assumption is that race and sexuality are exactly the same then the above paragraph is simply unthinkable. We don't negotiate with terrorists and we don't tolerate racists.
4. This broke my heart this morning. I have a black, five-year-old daughter, and I know there is coming a day when I’ll have to explain to her that there are still people in this world that will hate her simply because she is black. Now, unless something changes radically in our culture, I fear that I’ll also have to explain to her that if she dares to hold historic Christian convictions in public, there will be people who will hate her for that too. She could lose a job or worse over her deeply held convictions.
5. We'd all be better off if we spent a bit more time reflecting on this piece from Brandon Ambrosino.
6. The sky is not falling. Jesus is still on the throne. Godliness implies persecution (2 Tim 3:12). We’ll be ok. This life is a mist. This is nothing new and many Christians around the world are persecuted WAY worse than some reality TV star losing his job.
Books by Russell Moore:
Tuesday, November 26, 2013
Monday, November 25, 2013
Disrespect and Facebook
Sometimes, evangelical Christians do more harm than good on Facebook.
Under the veil of “taking a stand” for our values, I fear we are letting loose all kinds of dishonoring, uncharitable speech. We need to stop.Read the rest.
Books by Trevin Wax:
Monday, October 21, 2013
"What happens to a country when its young people stop having sex? Japan is finding out…"
There is wisdom in the command to "be fruitful and multiply." It blesses culture. When you go the other way huge problems can and will ensue. Japan is starting to feel the consequences of a culture that doesn't embrace a biblical doctrine of creation.
(There is a bit of crassness in the link article.)
(There is a bit of crassness in the link article.)
Wednesday, August 21, 2013
Taking the Swagger Out of Christian Cultural Influence
John Piper:
(HT: Jared)
Being Christian exiles in American culture does not end our influence; it takes the swagger out of it. We don’t get cranky that our country has been taken away. We don’t whine about the triumphs of evil. We are not hardened with anger. We understand. This is not new. This was the way it was in the beginning — Antioch, Corinth, Athens, Rome . . . It never occurred to those early exiles that they should rant about the ubiquity of secular humanism. The Imperial words were still ringing in their ears: “You will be hated by all for my name’s sake. But the one who endures to the end will be saved” (Mark 13:13). This was a time for indomitable joy and unwavering ministries of mercy.Read the rest.
(HT: Jared)
Friday, July 26, 2013
Would You Consider Human Trafficking a "Religious" Issue?
Helpful article here dealing with the objection to pro-lifers that is commonly phrased as, "Keep your religion to yourself" in the abortion debate.
Tuesday, April 09, 2013
“I Don’t Like to Think in Terms of Culture Wars“
Great thoughts here from Dr. Russell Moore. I would encourage you to watch the C-SPAN video.
Books by Russell Moore:
Books by Russell Moore:
Saturday, March 16, 2013
Ed Stetzer on the Rise of the "Nones"
Books by Ed Stetzer:
- Planting Missional Churches
- Compelled: Living the Mission of God
- Subversive Kingdom: Living as Agents of Gospel Transformation
- Transformational Church: Creating a New Scorecard for Congregations
- Lost and Found: The Younger Unchurched and the Churches that Reach Them
- Comeback Churches: How 300 Churches Turned Around and Yours Can, Too
- Breaking the Missional Code: Your Church Can Become a Missionary in Your Community
- Viral Churches: Helping Church Planters Become Movement Makers (Jossey-Bass Leadership Network Series)
Monday, March 11, 2013
Thursday, February 28, 2013
"The talking faces of the post-evangelical Jello salad..."
Jared Wilson:
Jared's Books:
In the days coming, a regular re-reading of the book of Jude might be in order. The talking faces of the post-evangelical Jello salad want to help evangelicals navigate the uncharted waters of post-Christendom. But Jesus gave us plenty of words about unfaithful stewards and hired hands. We can learn nothing from the heterodox about navigating “the future of evangelicalism” except how to shut the engines off and drift.Well said. Read the rest.
Jared's Books:
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)




