Tuesday, May 26, 2009

Is Spanking Abusive?

Doug Wilson shares a brief article about the discipline of children and especially the method of spanking. As usual, he is articulate, funny and very instructive. I thought this paragraph was very helpful:
People who do not know how to look beyond surface appearances will say that when you spank a child you are teaching them violence. They say spanking a child is hitting a child, and they are impatient with those who seek to make fundamental distinctions. Lovemaking is not rape, even though the same biological act is involved in both. Executing Ted Bundy is not imitating Ted Bundy, even though someone loses his life in both instances. The difference between child abuse and child discipline is as vast as the difference between unrighteousness and righteousness.


Godly discipline, spanking included, is an act of love. Children who are disciplined appropriately know that they are being loved, and they know that the world is a secure place. Boundaries exist, and those boundaries are defended by parents who love the boundaries, just as they love their children. Children who are not corrected and spanked when they need it know that their parents are actually exhibiting a hatred of them (Prov. 13:24). This is what Scripture teaches, and so we may safely assert it. But having done so, we are also invited to taste the godly fruit of obedience in this. The Scriptures are not true in a vacuum; they speak the truth to us, about us, and concerning us. Whenever we obey, trusting God for the blessing, the results are what the Bible promises to glad obedience.
Especially if you are a parent of young children, (like me), I would encourage you to read his post.

2 comments:

amy said...

well said.

M&M in Japan said...

Good post Z. Spanking is definitely something that can be abused. Not spanking can also be abuse. I am learning the balance and this article helped. Thanks.