Back to my angry and ungrateful critique of the industry that helps to feed my family! I’ll probably go down in flames one of these days, but if you are reading this right now then that makes you one of about 5 so I should be in good shape for a bit.
In all seriousness I don’t want to sound angry and ungrateful. I am very honored to work in the areas that I do and I know that there are literally hundreds of guys in Nashville that would die to have the opportunities that I have been given. I don’t view this lightly. I think more than anything I want to document some of the thoughts that are rolling around in my head as I think about our faith and how it is presented in the business of Christianity. On with the negativity!!!
Generally speaking, Christian radio does not challenge. To me this renders it at best a means for encouragement, but at worst just a warm and fuzzy, superficial kind of listening.
One of the main slogans that you frequently hear from one of the Christian radio stations here in Nashville is, “Safe for the whole family”. I understand what they mean when they say that and I totally value the guarding of my ears and ears of my kids from profanity and sexual messages, but maybe we just shouldn’t use the word “safe” when it comes to Christianity. I have to ask, what is safe about the gospel? Would the martyrs listed in the book of Hebrews say it was safe? Would Paul say that the gospel is safe? It certainly wasn’t safe for Jesus. World missions is not safe. The crushing of my pride is not safe. Taking radical risks of faith for the sake of your calling is not safe.
With all it’s good intentions I fear that the underlying message of the “safe for the whole family” may be doing harm than good. I know that I cherish my safety and comfort. It’s the cultural air we breathe in the USA. In one sense I am very thankful for this, but it is also dangerous to my soul because I believe the God’s ultimate aim for his people is far from being “safe”. For the sake of the gospel I think we need less “safety” or cherishing of this ideal and more risk-taking crazy faith-filled endeavors.
Where is the challenge? As Christians don’t we need strong messages to wake us from our slumber and continue to fight for faith in our daily lives? There are some songs that do this and are extremely powerful. Ginny Owen’s “If you want me to” or Casting Crowns (though I’m not a big fan of the music) “If we are the body” are great examples of songs that are allowed to be played on Christian radio that challenge us to live different. (There are probably hosts of others that I am not thinking of) I am very thankful that these messages have gotten through on Christian airwaves. Unfortunately it’s not the norm.
Over the years I have been greatly encouraged by the ministry of John Piper. I know that for the sake of getting people’s attention he often times says things in such a way as to awaken people to say “huh?” This year at Passion06 here in Nashville I know that he had some people thinking that he was straight nuts, but I know this for sure, he got peoples attention and they were talking about it and thinking about it after the conference. This happens all the time in Biblical preaching. Why can’t it happen in Christian music and more specifically on Christian radio? It’s probably because Christian radio is dominated for the most part by money and God-glorifying preaching doesn’t have money as it’s bottom line. I know that music will probably never take the place of strong preaching, but I think that more strong preaching needs to take place in the music that we listen to as Christians.
Where are the messages in music on Christian radio that awaken us and rattle us? I think I fear that Christian radio at times sinks into the “what itching ears want to hear” category. I fear that radio stations are feeling like they have to give us Christians the warm and fuzzy messages that we need to help us “be positive” throughout the day and then the money will keep coming in and it all goes around again. At the end of the day though, I think this renders it potentially meaningless. Unfortunately, growth usually never happens when we are comfortable.
I few months back I turned in a song to my publisher that had the line “Sitting Sunday’s in the front and everyone they know them well, but do they know that their marriage is hell?” I was told that you can’t use the word “hell” in a Christian song. Why not? I could understand it a bit better if you just tell me that it’s not a well crafted line in my song, but please don’t tell me you can’t use very Biblical word “hell” in a song.
Solutions? – Writers need to be able to say things that challenge. Publishers need to take the risk of challenging those who will purchase Christian music. Jointly, writers and publishers need to know that they will have an outlet for this challenge. Radio station owners need to have the courage to give our people maybe a message that is a bit uncomfortable for the sake of growth, and since it’s a business there has to be money given to support it.